Teaching Guide
The study questions are designed to meet common core state standards, and can be used as writing prompts, essay questions, or springboards for group discussion. They’re suitable for civics and government classes, or English composition and rhetoric. The study questions generally progress in difficulty.
Note: This study guide is included in the paperback version.
CHAPTER 1
What is the difference between a crime and bad behavior?
Consider the dangers of smoking to the smoker and the entire society. Are there behaviors that are less dangerous to individuals and society that are illegal? Consider what would happen if smoking was criminalized.
What would happen if all bad behaviors were crimes?
Do you think what James Rogers did should be considered a crime? Why or why not?
Do you think what Brian Wrzesinsky did should be considered a crime? Why or why not?
Choose two of the three cases discussed in this chapter. Compare and contrast the wrongs committed. Decide which was worse, and why.
Can juries ever be 100% sure about the facts? Why or why not?
What is the difference between a trial court and a court of appeal?
Do you think it is enough for a majority of jurors or justices to believe a person should be found guilty, or do you think there should be a unanimous decision before a person can be convicted of a crime? Why or why not?
What main point, or argument, is the author making in this chapter?
How does the author support her points or arguments?
How well does the author support her points or arguments?
Analyze in detail how an author’s ideas or claims are developed and refined by particular sentences, paragraphs, or larger portions of a text.
Consider how laws are passed. Can you think of any reasons banks might have special laws with special definitions of theft? Should banks be treated differently than other businesses? Why or why not?
CHAPTER 2
Explain, in your own words, how the banks increased their income from bank fees between the mid-1990s and 2008.
Was the way they increased their revenue fair?
Should banks have the right to charge whatever fees they want? After all, customers can choose to go elsewhere.
Why did the customers believe the bank policy was wrong?
How did the banks defend their behavior? Did you agree?
Why did the author include an entire chapter on the lawsuits over the bank fees? What point was she trying to make? Did you agree?
How might you argue that what James Rogers did was worse than what the banks did and more deserving of punishment?
How might you argue that what the banks did was worse than what James Rogers did?
Can you make an argument for why the behavior of both the banks and James Rogers should be noncriminal matters decided in private lawsuits between citizens?
Can you make an argument for why the behavior of both the banks and James Rogers should be criminal matters, carrying state-imposed punishments?
Can you tell how the author feels about the behavior of the banks? If so, how can you tell? Did she present the facts in an even-handed manner, or did she slant in one direction or the other?
CHAPTER 3
Compare what Timothy Childs did in the casino to what James Rogers did in the bank. Which was worse? Why?
Compare what Mr. Woods did to what James Rogers did. Which was worse? Why?
Cheating is bad, but not all forms of cheating are criminal. Cheating in a game on the playground may lose you friends, but cheating in the classroom on a test may get you expelled. When should cheating be a crime, and when should it be a matter for a civil lawsuit or other private means of settling disputes?
On page 21, we are told that courts are not supposed to create law. Courts are supposed to interpret the law. Congress creates law. Why are courts not to create law? What would happen if courts wrote the laws and interpreted the laws?
When the Nevada Supreme Court declared the handle-popping statute unconstitutionally vague, was the Nevada Supreme Court in fact creating a law?
What general argument, or point, was the author making in this chapter?
Consider what might happen if another branch of government had the task of interpreting the Constitution.
CHAPTER 4
What general point is the author making in this chapter?
Did you agree with the arguments made by the American military about why Huzaifa and the others should be kept in prison?
The Supreme Court, in deciding that the Separate Car Act was constitutional, said that segregation does not imply that one race is inferior to the other as long as the separate facilities are equal. If you were the lawyer representing Mr. Plessy, how might you try to explain to the Supreme Court that it was wrong?
Homer Plessy’s strategy for challenging the Separate Car Act was possible because, thanks to Marbury v. Madison, courts interpret the Constitution and decide which laws are constitutional. Explain how that is true.
Can you think of any times when the military should be allowed to keep people in prison without regular courts interfering?
CHAPTER 5
Should it be a crime for parents to spank their children?
Attitudes about whether husbands should be allowed to beat wives have changed over the years. Can you think of other attitudes that have changed? Do you and your parents have different ideas about what sorts of behavior should be considered crimes? What about you and your grandparents?
The North Carolina Supreme Court believed that finding Elizabeth’s husband guilty would cause a greater harm and danger to society than the injuries she received from his battering her. What did the court mean?
What do you think the North Carolina Supreme Court meant by the paragraph beginning “Suppose a case came to us from a hovel . . .” Consider that this case was decided in the South about twenty years after the Civil War. One of the issues in the Civil War was that states should be able to govern themselves however they wished, including allowing slavery, without the federal government interfering. Do the year and place shed light on some of the court’s attitudes?
CHAPTER 6
Do you think the United States military was justified in killing Osama bin Laden instead of trying to bring him to trial?
Do you think Anthony Fowler should have been found guilty of something? (If not murder, perhaps a lesser offense?)
The death penalty remains controversial, with some people defending the death penalty and others opposed. How do you feel?
If you are opposed to the death penalty, can you think of cases in which the death penalty might be warranted?
Do you believe there are instances in which killing should not be considered a crime?
Many states divide the crime of murder into various levels, with first degree the most serious, second degree less serious, and crimes called manslaughter even less serious. Can you think of killings that should not be considered as serious and would carry lesser penalties?
CHAPTER 7
What are some arguments in favor of using punishment for retribution?
What are some arguments against using punishment for retribution?
Which way do you think the author leans? Why?
Which way do you lean? Why?
Have you seen instances of retribution in your own life?
Why is Marvin’s story in this chapter? What point is the author making about the theory of retribution through the use of Marvin’s story?
Do you think people with low intelligence should be spared the death penalty? Why or why not?
“Jury nullification” is the term used when a jury finds a defendant not guilty even though the jurors believe the defendant is guilty. Why do you think jurors might do this? Can you think of good reasons for jurors to do this? Can you think of bad reasons for jurors to do this?
CHAPTER 8
The author lists problems with the theory of deterrence. What are they?
The story of Nick Horner is used to illustrate what point?
Nick Horner was sentenced to life in prison. Do you think this was fair? Why or why not?
The author says deterrence often won’t prevent the most horrific crimes. Why? Do you agree?
The stories of Charles Whitman and the high school teacher in Virginia are used to illustrate what point?
How does the author feel about tough criminal laws? Does the author believe they work as deterrence? How do you know? What do you think?
The author points out problems with using incapacitation to prevent crimes. What are they?
Clarence Darrow, a famous defense lawyer, claimed that nobody should be in prison. Can you think of how Mr. Darrow might have supported his position?
CHAPTER 9
What is due process of law?
What is equal protection of the laws?
There is much debate over states rights versus a strong national government. What are the advantages of a strong federal government? What are the advantages of a weaker federal government with more rights and powers given to the states?
Do you think the exclusionary rule is a good idea? Or do you believe there is a better way to make sure the police respect individual rights?
CHAPTER 10
When you read the account of Clarence’s first trial, did you believe he was guilty?
Did his history of convictions made you more likely to think he was guilty?
Compare the Clarence’s two trials. Why do you think Clarence’s lawyer, W. Fred Turner, could do a better job?
Do you agree with the Supreme Court that the Fourteenth Amendment (requiring due process of law and equal protection of the laws) requires the government to provide lawyers for people who cannot afford them?
It was not until 1986, in a case called Batson v. Kentucky, that the United States Supreme Court said it was unconstitutional to exclude people from a jury based on their race. Previously it was common for an all-white jury to convict a non-white defendant. Explain how the requirements of the Fourteenth Amendment (due process of law and equal protection of the laws) forbids excluding people from a jury based on race.
CHAPTER 11
Are there rules at home or school that you believe are unfair? Can you make a good argument for why the rules should be changed?
How might you convince those in authority to change those rules?
What did Clarence Darrow mean when he said “It’s not the bad people I fear so much as the good people. When a person is sure that he is good, he is nearly hopeless. He gets cruel. He believes in punishment.” Do you agree? Why or why not?
CONCLUSION
What did Thomas Szasz mean when he said mental illnesses are largely myths and ways of letting people escape personal responsibility? Do you agree? Why or why not?
What did Fyodor Dostoevsky mean when he said, “The degree of civilization in a society can be judged by entering its prisons”? Do you agree? Why or why not?


