I. How to Conduct a Mock Trial: A Guide

Pick a Case. To take an example of how to proceed, let’s start with Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District, a case that tests the limits of a student’s free speech rights in school. (In Tinker, there was no jury, but there is no reason not to have one for a class exercise.)

You can find the case explained in Chapter One of Rebels, Robbers, and Radicals. For additional resources, check out Oyez, operated by Justia and Cornell’s Legal Information Institute. I have found that Oyez offers excellent and accurate summaries of important legal cases. The best resource, of course, is the Supreme Court opinion itself. (Oddly, appellate decisions are called “opinions.”) Justia offers the full text of the major cases.

Assign Roles.  For Tinker, you will need the following:

  • Mary Beth Tinker (witness, student)
  • Christopher Eckhardt (witness, student)
  • John Tinker (witness, student)
  • The principal who sends the kids home (witness)
  • A defense team for the school (2–4 lawyers)
  • A legal team for the students (2–4 lawyers)
  • A judge (It might not be a bad idea, depending on the level of the class, for the teacher to be the judge.)
  • A jury (an odd number would be helpful so you can allow the majority to decide)
  • You will need the following for the appeal:
    • A lawyer (or small team) representing the winning party
    • A lawyer (or small team) representing the losing party
    • A panel of appellate justices (the Supreme Court has 9, but any odd number, including  3, works.)

If all your students want to be on the side they think is “right,” consider this true story:

A law school moot court competition concerned a death penalty case. Given the race of the defendant, the year, and location, it was immediately apparent to the students that racism was involved. Law Student #1 said, “I can’t be the prosecutor in this case. I just can’t.” His opponent, who agreed that in real life she would not have been able to prosecute that particular case, agreed to take the role of prosecutor. The defense was so sure he would win (in his view, the prosecutor was clearly biased!) that he didn’t work as hard as he should have to understand what the prosecutor might argue. The student who played the part of the prosecutor won the competition because she understood her opponent better.

Sometimes you are better off arguing the more difficult side.

In the words of John Stuart Mill, “He who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that.”

Time: Preparing for the trial and conducting the trial would likely take at least a few days and would likely take at least a week, depending on the level of the class and the level of detail they can handle.

During the trial the appellate group (lawyers and appellate justices) watch carefully. If they can, they should take notes. This allows them to understand the case as presented, and replaces what appellate lawyers and justices do in real life: They read and study a transcript from the trial and they examine all of the evidence presented.

Opening Statements

To prepare for the trial, lawyers should have their opening statements prepared. They should write their closing arguments after witnesses are examined and evidence is presented.

The trial opens when one of the lawyers for the plaintiffs presents opening statements, laying out the case against the school and the evidence to be presented. There should be a time limit.

Then one of the lawyers for the school offers an opening statement. The same time limit should apply.

The Plaintiffs Present Their Case

The lawyers for the plaintiffs call their first witness and ask questions. The defense is then allowed to cross examine. After that, plaintiffs are allowed redirect, which is a chance to clean up any damage. (You might also consider time limits here, or give the judge the authority to move things along.)

Each of the witnesses are questioned in this manner.

(The easiest way to present any physical evidence is through the examination or cross-examination.)

The Defense Presents Its Case

The procedure is the same. The lawyers call witnesses, question them, and then the plaintiffs lawyer cross-examine. The defense can then redirect (ask more questions.)

The jury mostly listens. If a juror has questions, they can submit them to the judge in writing.

The judge keeps order.

Closing Arguments

First the plantiffs and then the defense offer closing arguments. (There should be time limits.)

Jury Instructions

The judge tells the jury what law they are applying and what issues the jury is deciding. Here is an example:

Your job is to determine what happened and decide the outcome based on the guidelines I will give you.

Guidelines: Students do not lose their right to free speech when they walk into school. Wearing an armband to express a political opinion is a form of speech. A school may forbid student speech only if it shows that the speech would substantially disrupt the work of the school or interfere with the rights of other students. A general fear of trouble is not enough. Neither is officials’ wish to avoid the discomfort of an unpopular opinion. To decide for the school district, you must find that school officials had evidence, not just worry, that the armbands would cause substantial disruption.

The Jury Deliberates

The jury goes into a huddle to weigh strength of the evidence.

The Jury Issues A Verdict

The Appeal

(Note that the Supreme Court is an appellate court. It is also the highest appellate court. Most court systems have a three-part structure that looks like this: Trial Court-Appellate Court-Supreme Court. For classroom purposes, you can combine the two appellate steps.)

On appeal, no new evidence can be presented, and no witnesses are called. The appellate court examines what happened at the trial and looks for errors. The Supreme Court interprets the Constitution, so the Supreme Court decides how the First Amendment should be applied to individual cases. The Supreme Court, for example, is free to decide that the lower court applied the wrong law or the wrong standard.

The Hearing

The losing side goes first. A lawyer representing the losing side gets a limited time to explain to the appellate justices what went wrong at the trial. The losing side can argue that the law applied by the trial court is inconsistent with the Bill of Rights. In other words, lawyers can argue that the Constitution requires a different rule, and a different rule could lead to a different outcome.

The appellate justices ask the lawyers hard questions (because that is how they probe the strength of the arguments).

Then the winning side gets a turn to defend the decision of the lower court.

Again the justices ask hard questions.

The Appellate Justices Deliberate

The appellate justices go into a huddle to discuss the issues and evidence.

The Appellate Court Renders a Decision

For a mock appeal, I’d give the appellate justices two options: Affirm what the lower court did and explain. Overturn what the lower court did and explain. (In real life they can also send the issue back for a retrial.)

II.  Ideas for Other Trials

Any of the cases in Rebels, Robbers, and Radicals or Guilty? can lend themselves to a trial.

Bright-Line Rules versus Standards

Here is another idea. Let your students examine bright-line rules versus standards.

A bright-line rule is easier to apply but can result in injustice. Standards are harder to apply and are more subject to bias but can offer more justice. In practice, a standard is more likely to invite arguments. The question is whether that is a bad thing.

Let your students put this question to the test: “Should there be a fundamental fairness doctrine governing household or school rules?”
Consider this (familiar) issue: Is “one hour of screen time per day” (a bright-line rule) preferable to this general standard that might look like this: “A reasonable amount, once your homework is done.”

Create an actual dispute, like this one. One sibling procrastinates doing homework, is easily distracted, and gets poor grades. The other is a straight-A student who always finishes her homework on time. The straight-A student challenges the household rule of “one hour per day of screen time,” arguing that the rule is fundamentally unfair and should be replaced with a more flexible standard.

The plaintiff challenges the bright-line rule as fundamentally unfair and argues that there should be a “fundamental fairness doctrine” governing household or school rules.

Consider Putting This Argument to the Test in a Trial

Mother: “Do not talk that way!”

Teenager: “What about my right to free speech?”

Mother: “The restriction applies only to the government. I am not the government.”

Teenager: “In this house you are like the government.”  (The teenager’s argument is not a bad one! See Marsh v. Alabama (1946) in which the Supreme Court held that a company town owned entirely by a private company, Chickasaw, Alabama, was bound by the First Amendment because it functioned like a government.)

Scroll to Top