Teaching Guide

This guide follows these two principles:
Ask Hard Questions
It’s All About the Story
Prologue
Hard Questions
- Is it true that democracy works best when citizens are “shaped by a common climate and culture”?
- What are the advantages of a strong central government? What are the advantages of a weak central government with more power in the states?
- Can you think of a situation today that might cause people to prefer power residing in the states? (Hint: What if the federal government and courts come to be dominated by people with ideas you find abhorrent?)
- Does “guilty” always mean “wrong”?
- If you are playing cards with your friends and you cheat, is that wrong? Should it be a crime?
- Was Homer Plessy guilty? Was he wrong?
For more on the idea that not everything that is wrong is a crime, and not everything that is a crime is wrong, see my book Guilty? Crime, Punishment, and the Changing Face of Justice.
- Are there times when breaking the law is the moral course of action? (Think of people during the era of enslavement who helped those enslaved escape. What, then, should be the consequences?)
Chapter 1:
The First Amendment
Stories (shortened versions)
In 1860, a Mississippi law made it a punishable crime to use language “having a tendency to promote discontent among free colored people or insubordination among slaves.” (Speaking against slavery could violate the law.)
In 1919, a man named Benjamin Gitlow was on the managing board of the Socialist Party newspaper. He arranged for the printing of 16,000 copies of a manifesto advocating a Communist revolution in the United States. He was arrested and charged with violating a law that made it a crime to advocate for the violent overthrow of the government.
During a large rally of Ku Klux Klan members, one of the leaders said that if the government continues to suppress the White race, “it’s possible that there might have to be some revengeance taken.” The leader was arrested and charged under a law that made it a crime to advocate violence as a means of political change.
A man walks up to the bank teller and says, “Give me all your money or I will shoot.”
Hard Questions
Overarching Question: How far can a democracy outlaw or try to control speech and remain a democracy? Remember that every democracy restricts some speech, such as threats or blackmail.
Questions
- Should we outlaw offensive speech or dangerous speech?
-
-
-
- How should such a law be phrased? As a bright-line rule or a balancing test?
- If a balancing test, how would you phrase the criteria?
- If a bright-line rule, what rule would you offer?
-
-
- Is there ever a time when speech must be regulated in the interests of national security? (Planning a rebellion, revealing troop movements in wartime.)
- Is urging people to overthrow the government different from urging an angry crowd to attack a building right now?
Evaluate this argument a teenager has with her mother.
Mother: “Do not talk that way!”
Teenager: “What about my right to free speech?”
Mother (who is also a lawyer): “The restriction applies only to the government. I am not the government.”
Teenager: “In this house you are like the government.” (The teenager’s argument is not a bad one! See Marsh v. Alabama (1946) in which the Supreme Court held that a company town owned entirely by a private company, Chickasaw, Alabama, was bound by the First Amendment because it functioned like a government.)
Chapter 2:
The Second Amendment
A Few Stories
In 1776, a band of rebels rebelled against the government on the grounds that the government had grown tyrannical, overthrew that government, and set up a new government. In 1791, the following was added to the Constitution:
“A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”
Thirteen-year-old Daniel Southwell’s family understands that they have a constitutional right to form a militia and overthrow the federal government should government grow tyrannical.
High schoolers David Hogg and Emma González, who survived a school shooting, insist that the phrase “a well regulated Militia” means “militias formed under the authority of the government,” and that nothing in the Second Amendment allows individual unfettered access to guns.
Hard Questions
- Who is right, the Southwell family or Hogg and González?
- If the Southwell family is right, can anyone overthrow the government if it grows tyrannical? Who decides what is “tyrannical”?
- What does “well regulated” mean?
- When, under the Second Amendment, can the government limit who can own guns?
- The people who wrote the Second Amendment had muskets. Can the Second Amendment protect weapons they couldn’t have imagined?
Chapter 3:
The Third Amendment
(From here on, I will skip the stories because they are included in the book.)
Hard Questions
Can you think of any situation today in which the Third Amendment might be invoked?
The Third Amendment has served no purpose since the advent of army bases.
(Note: There is a provision in the Quartering Act that allowed soldiers to be housed in private homes if drink was also sold there, and in fact, soldiers were housed in private homes.)
Chapter 4:
The Fourth Amendment
Do you agree with the exclusionary rule? If not, can you think of any other way to deter police from illegal searches?
- Under which circumstances do you think public school officials should be permitted to search students’ lockers, backpacks, and persons?
- Is it a search if a police dog sniffs you in an airport? What are your privacy rights in an airport? If it is a search, is it reasonable?
Chapter 5:
The Fifth Amendment
- Rules protecting suspects during police questioning mean that some guilty people may go free. Is this a good thing or a bad thing? In other words, do you agree that it is better “that ten guilty persons escape, than that one innocent suffer”?
- How would you define “due process”?
- Do you think it should be a violation of the rule against double jeopardy for a person to be tried in both state and federal court for the same crime?
- How is the grand jury requirement a check on executive power?
- Is eminent domain fair? Why or why not?
- Analyze the term “regulatory takings.” What things might fall under such a label?
Chapter 6:
The Sixth Amendment
- Is there (or should there be) a difference between the right to a lawyer and the right to a government-paid lawyer?
- Explain the relationship between the right to confront one’s accusers and the rule against hearsay.
- Can you think of any reasons today why a person might insist on being tried in the location where the alleged crime occurred? (Possible answers: A local jury knows the place, people, and circumstances. The accused will have access to witnesses and evidence. A distant trial costs more for the defendant. It is a check on government power because it prevents a prosecutor from “forum shopping” or looking for a location where the local laws favor the prosecution.)
Chapter 7:
The Seventh Amendment
- Why did early Americans believe juries were “vital to a free people”?
- If you were in legal trouble, when might you want a jury and when might you prefer a judge? (Possible answers: Given the facts, a person might be afraid the jury would decide based on pure emotion. If the best argument is a legal one, a judge might be more open to what a jury might consider a technicality.)
Chapter 8:
The Eighth Amendment
- How should courts determine whether bail is “excessive”?
- Do you agree (with the Supreme Court) that the Bail Reform Act is constitutional?
- In the law, we talk about bright-line rules versus standards or balancing tests. A bright-line rule is easier to apply but can result in injustice. On the other hand, standards or balancing tests are harder to apply and are more subject to bias. Can you think of any bright-line rules for determining whether bail is excessive or whether a person can be subjected to pretrial detention?
- Can you come up with some standards for determining whether bail is excessive or whether a person can be subjected to pretrial detention? Test your standards with invented hypotheticals like this: Suppose a billionaire and a person earning minimum wage are both arrested for the same crime. How should bail for each be determined?
- Do you think the death penalty should be considered cruel and unusual punishment?
Chapter 9:
The Ninth Amendment
The Constitution doesn’t list every right. Should judges protect rights that aren’t written down? If so, who decides which ones?
Advanced question: Do you agree with the Supreme Court that the Bill of Rights, read together with the Ninth Amendment, protects a right to privacy? Try to argue both sides of the question.
Chapter 10:
The Tenth Amendment
Some decisions are made by your town, some by your state, and some by the national government. Who should decide the age you can get a driver’s license? What you learn in school? Whether you can own a gun? Why?
Is it better to have one rule for the whole country, or to let each state make its own rules? What are the advantages of each?
Before the Civil War, Southern states said they had the right to decide for themselves whether to allow slavery. When should the national government be allowed to overrule a state? Consider the fact that US presidents and members of Congress change regularly.

